15 Best Pumpkin Pasties Recipes for Harry Potter Lovers

Pumpkin Pasties Recipes

Disclosure: This pumpkin pasties recipe page contains affiliate links. Read full Disclosure Policy.

Pumpkin pasties are some of the most popular Harry Potter recipes. Also check out our list of butterbeer recipes, and our round-up of Harry Potter cakes.

We’ve rounded up a huge collection of the best pumpkin pasties recipes!

Pumpkin pasties are a traditional British dish made of pastry filled with a sweetened pumpkin filling and then baked. They’re similar to American pie, but they’re more savory and less sweet. They can be eaten warm or cold, depending on your preference.

We’ve assembled the best pumpkin pasties recipes to transport you to the magical world of Harry Potter. Harry & Ron Weasley bonded on Hogwarts Express over pumpkin pasties in Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone.

Pumpkin Pasties

The best part about the pumpkin pasty is that it’s relatively easy to make—all you need is some pastry dough, pastry cutters (or a knife), and some canned pumpkin!

You can even use leftover canned pumpkin from other baking projects as long as it’s still soft enough to work with.

Here are the pumpkin pasty recipes!

1. Pumpkin Pasties from Blue Bowl

These indulgences are made with flaky, buttery, homemade pie crust and stuffed with a mouthwatering maple pumpkin filling.

2. Savory Pumpkin Pasties, Inspired by Harry Potter

Are Harry Potter pumpkin pasties sweet or savory?

It isn’t clearly outlined in the books, but since many English pasty recipes are traditionally savory, try this version for a different taste. We think Hagrid would approve.

3. Glazed Harry Potter Pumpkin Pasties

Are pumpkin pasties real?

Yes – the pasties featured in Harry Potter book series are in fact real recipes you can make. This recipe features a spiced pumpkin filling, inside a crumbly cinnamon pastry, topped with a sweet glaze.

4. Add a Lightning Bolt to this Recipe

Can we ask Dobby to bring us a few of these?

We like the special flourish added to these pasties by The Gingered Whisk of Harry Potter’s scar. Expelliarmus!

5. Easy to Follow Step By Step Tutorial

The recipe at Brownie Bites has great step-by-step images to walk you through the pasty creation process.

6. Dumbledore Would Approve

Another name for a pumpkin pasty is a pumpkin hand pie. Try your hand at making this Harry Potter treat. And save one for Dumbledore!

7. Must Make Harry Potter Pumpkin Pasty

Filled with pumpkin pie spice, brown sugar, canned pumpkin puree. Serve with a flagon of Butterbeer.

8. Harry Potter Pumpkin Pasties Recipe

Inspired by the Honeydukes Sweet Shop at the Wizarding World of Harry Potter at Universal Studios, this copycat recipe will help you relive warm Harry Potter memories.

9. Pumpkin Pasties from Harry Potter

Anything off the trolley, dears?

Life tip: Don’t pass up these Harry Potter inspired pumpkin pasties if they’re offered.

10. Pumpkin Pasties from Where is My Spoon

Did you know that the pumpkin pasty was the first food we read about in Harry Potter?

On his way to Hogwarts on the Hogwarts Express, he shares some of these treats with new friend, Ron Weasley.

11. Perfect Pasties for a Potter Party

Some of our favorites on this list come from Favorite Family Recipes; they are specialists in copycat recipes and deserve a spot in our collection.

12. Serve These Warm, With Ice Cream

You can serve pumpkin pasties warm or cold. They are great leftover too as a grab and go mini pumpkin pie snack.

13. Savory Pumpkin Pasty, Inspired by the Harry Potter Books

In this post, Catherine Clark provides two versions of pumpkin pasties, but we’re highlighting her savoury version.

Garlic, sage, cheese and spices make her pumpkin-filled pasty a savory fall treat.

14. Is a Pasty a Turnover?

Another name for a pumpkin pasty is a handmade pumpkin turnover. In this recipe, The Toasty Kitchen teaches how to make pumpkin turnovers with a store-bought pie crust or a handmade crust.

15. Harry Potter Pumpkin Hand Pies

For Halloween? Or a Harry Potter party? Or whenever you want! These pumpkin hand pies, inspired by the J.K. Rowling book series, look great and taste delicious too.

Enjoy at your next Harry Potter party.


Pumpkin pasties are perfect for a Harry Potter celebration or just to enjoy on fall day!

A pumpkin pasty is a savory, puff pastry-wrapped pumpkin pie with a flaky, buttery crust and a flaky, buttery filling. It’s a tasty combination of savory and sweet that will take your taste buds to new heights.

Pumpkin pasties are best eaten warm out of the oven, but they can also be enjoyed at room temperature or chilled in the refrigerator.

And whether you’re looking for something cute and portable or something that can feed a crowd, this list has a recipe that will fit you perfectly.

Which of these pumpkin pasty recipes was your favorite? Let us know in the comments below!

0/5 (0 Reviews)

0 0 votes
Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments